Properly spicy.
I usually don't eat pie crust (too boring), but even the crust is delicious.
I'm glad you stopped including rum - that doesn't belong in pumpkin pie. This version is perfect.
We ordered two pumpkin pies from The Meat Guy for this year's Thanksgiving dinner and they were absolutely delicious! Not too sweet with a great balance of pumpkin and spice, and a very light and crumbly graham cracker crust. Good size too, one pie is plenty for six people. Stays good for days refrigerated. Will definitely order again, a definite cut above Costco pies and the like.